Think of me what you may, but I am an online dater. I have met two past girlfriends through
Match.com and I've long since lost track of how many dozens upon dozens of first and last go nowhere dates I have been on since moving to the Twin Cities in 1999. Most of them I met via personals websites. Excuses? Regrets? I have none. Daunting as it can be, it's just a good way to meet single women without either party's judgment being impaired by alcohol (unless you tend to surf personals sites whilst drunkened by liquors). And if you are out there tsk, tsk, tsking at how pathetic I am, all I have to say to you is YOU ARE SITTING IN FRONT OF A COMPUTER READING MY BLOG!!! How's that for pathetic? Very. That's how pathetic. And how's that for answering my own rhetorical question for some reason? Very well. That's how it is.
Let's take a look at a few dating sites I use or have used in the past (yes, I really have used all of them at one time or another). Note that any observations about the types of people that seem to frequent particular sites or about the number of profiles that show up in searches are based strictly on my own personal criteria, which at a very broad level are single college-educated women in their mid 20's to early 30's with no children and who live in or near the Minneapolis-St Paul metro area. I'm willing to bet most of my observations can be extrapolated to other age groups and cities, but just something to keep in mind.
Next time: Tips for writing your profile.*
Match.com*
Cupid.com*
AmericanSingles*
LoveHappens*
Yahoo Personals*
Hot or Not*
City Pages Personals*
Lavalife*
Date.com*
eHarmony*
Chemistry*
MySpaceMatch.comMatch is arguably the 800-lb gorilla amongst dating sites. They were one of the first around to successfully build a business out of online dating and have honed their site design and tools to a science over the years. In my opinion, if you're only going to post a profile on one site, and especially if you're only going to pay for a full subscription to only one dating site, Match is far and above my top recommendation.
The crowd: All walks of life, all corners of the socioeconomic spectrum. In other words, real, honest to goodness normal people (interspersed with your garden variety loonies like you'd meet anywhere else in your offline life).
What's free: Posting a profile and photos, advanced searching, reading profiles, viewing one photo for each profile, receiving and reading messages and "Winks" (a way non paid members and lazy people can show someone they're interested without actually writing a message).
What's paid: Sending email. You can't even reply to email from paid members unless you yourself are a paid member. I also believe you must be a paid member to view photos other members have posted in their profiles, except the first one, which is viewable with a free account. For additional fees, you can have your profile highlighted to stand out in search results
How much: $34.99/month to $16.99/month if you prepay 6 months.
Best features: Reading and anonymously replying to messages from Match members from your email account instead of being tied to Match's website. Seeing which users looked at your profile. Quick glance summary of who recently wrote to you and vice-versa. Detailed advanced search let's you literally get as specific as "slender non-smoking food service workers with a dog and big boobs." Saving multiple advanced searches makes it easy to rerun them later. Filtering profiles of people you're not interested in from appearing in future searches. Multiple sorting options of profile search results.
Worst features: Seeing which users have looked at you is nice, but other users knowing you've looked at their profile seems to cause occasional undue excitement from other users thinking that just because you clicked on their profile, you want to marry them and populate a deserted planet with them. MindFindBind with Dr. Phil--this guy, the last person on earth I'd listen to for advice on dating, much less proper storage of milk, is plastered everywhere in the site. My guess is complaints from users tired of having his smarmy mug seared into their retinas at every turn prompted Match's recent addition of the "hide MindFindBind with Dr. Phil" option.
back to top
Cupid.comThe crowd: Probably people that have heard their ubiquitous ads on any number of local radio stations. They tout themselves as a site for meeting local people, somewhat underhandedly implying you can't meet local people on other sites. But the pickings compared to Match are quite slim for Minneapolis.
What's free: Posting a profile and photos, searching profiles, replying to messages sent to you by paid members, sending "Eye Contacts" (equivalent to Match's Winks).
What's paid: Sending messages.
How much: Pricing info wasn't available at the time of this posting. I will update it when I can get it.$29.95 per month down to $8.33 per month if you prepay 12 months.
Best features: Seeing who has looked at your profile, quick summary on front page of how many new messages and Eye Contacts you have. Hiding specific profiles from future searches. So-so live chat (see comment from Cupid employee at the end of this posting).
Worst features: Other people seeing you've looked at their profile, less detailed advanced search, no sorting options for search results. Can't save searches
or hide specific profiles from search results. (Per the comment from the Cupid employee below, I went back to the site and verified they do indeed now have this feature).
back to top
AmericanSinglesThe crowd: People less inclined to details like grammar, spelling, reading, and reading comprehension. Lots of fake decoy profiles posted by spammers.
What's free: Nothing of much value. You can post a profile and photos, search profiles and photos, and send "Flirts" like Match's Winks. You can't even read messages sent to you or see who sent them unless you are a paid member. Why bother?
What's paid: Sending messages, even just reading them or seeing who sent you messages!
How much: $29.99/month to $14.99/month if you prepay 5 months
Best features: Seeing who looked at your profile and who has "hot listed" you. Yes/No interest buttons next to profiles can give you immediate feedback of a potential match if the other person also clicked Yes on your profile.
Worst features: Others seeing that you looked at your profile. Each profile pops up in a new window when you click it. Advanced searches are anything but (you can't even filter out based on whether someone has or wants children, a staple of almost all other sites' advanced searches) Maddening tendency of their filters to randomly remove swaths of text from your profile to keep people from posting personal contact info in order to avoid paying for a subscription. Live chat interface is ponderous.
back to top
LoveHappens (formerly Tickle Dating, formerly Emode Dating)
The crowd: Slim pickings to say the least! Seems like it tends to be younger people (read teenies and immature early 20-somethings) who were probably drawn in by Tickle's "who's your inner rock star" type quizzes.
What's free: Posting a profile and photos, searching, viewing photos, sending. I also believe you can reply for free to messages sent by paid members.
What's paid: Sending messages.
How much: $20/month; keep the subscription active 6 months, and you are given a free lifetime paid membership.
Best features: Yes/No interest buttons next to profiles can give you (nearly) immediate feedback of a potential match if that person also clicked Yes on your profile. With your approval, friends and family can create non-dating profiles and post "testimonials" about you, though this feature is little used. Multiple saved advanced searches.
Worst features: Site layout and user interface in general are not intuitive and are dated, particularly in comparison to Match or Yahoo. Every screen seems to explode with visual clutter, making it difficult to find what you are looking for. No options for sorting search results.
back to top
Yahoo PersonalsOverall, I'd say Yahoo safely has the runner-up ribbon to Match's first place tiara. If you want to expand your dating horizons and plunk down money for two personals sites (you shameless online dating slut!!), swipe your credit card here, sign here, initial here, and pee in this cup.
The crowd: Much like Match, this one seems popular with about every walk of life you can imagine. Unfortunately, it also seems quite popular with spammers, though it seems like Yahoo is getting progressively better at preventing fake profiles from being posted.
What's free: Posting a profile and photos, searching profiles and viewing photos, sending Ice Breakers (like Match's Winks). Can't reply to messages sent by paid members unless you are also a paid member.
What's paid: Sending messages, even if you are replying to a message sent by another member, you must be a paid subscriber. For an additional fee, you can also subscribe to a more detailed personality-based matching option.
How much: $24.95/month to $12.49 if you prepay 6 months. Or for "Premier" service, the personality matching service, $39.95/month to $20.83/month if you prepay 6 months
Best features: Multiple saved advanced searches, keyword searching, numerous sorting and display options for search results, profiles often have more specific details like TV watching habits, attendance of religious services, and style of humor.
Worst features: The "Hide profile" feature tries unsuccessfully to mimic Match's ability to filter undesirable profiles from future search results but fails miserably. Hidden profiles seem to randomly pop up in the middle of search results, and the saved list of hidden profiles is sometimes reset and lost. The initial version also only allowed up to 100 profiles to be hidden. Also, you have to actually click on and open the profile to hide it. This feature is relatively new, and hopefully Yahoo will work out the kinks soon. Search results almost invariably contain duplicate listings of multiple profiles. Mouseover popup details in "gallery" view of search results often get in the way and are more annoying than useful.
back to top
Hot or NotThis site is known for letting desperately needy attention whores find out if they are Hot or Not (whoa, totally eponymous, dude!) by having their photo rated by the unwashed masses. Using their “Meet Me” feature, you can also meet some of those hot (or not) girls and guys for a date. Immediate rejection of ugly people has never been more socially acceptable than here.
The crowd: People that are really hot or horrendously ugly, like cute college girls and your mom, respectively. Teenies and 20-somethings that are looking for a bump and run, a date, and in rare case, true love (but maybe just a roll in the hay first, love).
What's free: Posting your profile and multiple photos. Replying to paid members who have written to you.
What's paid: Writing to other users (once both of you have clicked "Yes" on one another's profiles), sending virtual flowers.
How much: $6/month
Best features: Quick and simple interface. Quickly scan through photos, read the short blurb, and click Yes or No, then move onto the next profile.
Worst features: You only view one profile at time, and the order is completely random. Other than knowing a broad age range (18-25, 26-32, etc), you have no idea how old the person is unless they specifically mention it in their profile. The quick and simple interface also means scant availability of details about each person. There's no telling for sure if they are an 18 year old high school dropout or a 25 year old chemist working on a masters degree.
back to top
City Pages Personals (aka Onion Personals, etc)
City Pages Personals is actually a branded version of a personals site used by many other alternative weekly newspapers, including The Village Voice and The Onion.
The crowd: In addition to dorky white bread suburbanites like me, you can take your pick from those enjoying the tattooed and pierced world of urban hipsterdom.
What's free: Posting a profile and photo, viewing profiles and primary photos, very limited searching (age and gender), replying to messages from paid members, sending Winks.
What's paid: Advanced searches (location, height, has kids, religion, etc.), viewing all profile photos, writing to members. A higher tier of paid membership also grants priority for profile reviews and shows your profile before other members in search results.
How much: $34.94/month to about $9/month if you prepay 15 months (12 plus 3 free) or a lesser tier for $22.94/month to $9.94/month if you prepay 12 months.
Best features: Profiles have detailed and fun questions like "If I had a million dollars..." and "In my bedroom one will find..."
Worst features: Having to pay for advanced searching is just lame. A previous incarnation of the site allowed hiding specific profiles from search results like Match and Yahoo (well not like Yahoo since the City Pages version actually worked correctly), but that went bye bye with the new version of the site that was rolled out last year.
back to top
Lavalife (formerly WebPersonals)
The crowd: A small one, relatively speaking. This Toronto-based site has been around since the mid to late 90's, but doesn't seem to have quite the presence of the bigger players. Maybe it's a bigger deal in Canada like weed rolled in serviettes.
What's free: Creating and viewing profiles and photo, replying to messages from paid members, sending Smiles (like Match's Winks).
What's paid: Messaging is credit-based. Instead of paying a monthly fee, you purchase credits, which can be applied at any time to sending a message or initiating a video or text chat (chats are purchased in 30 minute increments). This is a nice option since if you see someone you like, you can pay to play without screwing around canceling recurring membership charges down the road.
How much: $14.99 for 50 credits to $39.99 for 200 credits. 6 credits for the first message you send to a person with no additional charge for future correspondence with that user. I couldn't find info on the cost of chat and video sessions.
Best features: Text and video chatting. Can optionally create a profile for each of three categories, Dating, Relationships, and Intimate (aka bump and run).
Worst features: Searches are limited. Site layout and user interface are cumbersome with draconian limitations like disabling right mouse clicks.
back to top
Date.com (aka MatchMaker)
The crowd: Two toothless women gathered around a jar of rotting mayo.
What's free: Posting and searching photos and profiles, "Showing Interest" like Match's Winks.
What's paid: Sending messages and replying to messages sent by paid members, text, voice, and video chat.
How much: $24.95/month to $7.99/month if you prepay 12 months
Best features: ?
Worst features: Searches aren't terribly advanced. Other than that, this site just doesn't offer stellar features that make it stand out amongst the others.
back to top
eHarmonyThe crowd: People looking for a lasting relationship through the magic of a computer telling them they should love each other.
What's free: Spending several hours going through their personality tests to post a profile and photos.
What's paid: Being matched up with and viewing profiles of people with neuroses that mesh nicely with your own.
How much: $59.95/month to $20.95/month if you prepay 12 months
Best features: The fancy schmancy matching system supposedly is quite picky about finding your match and will only show you people with compatible personality traits.
Worst features: Expensive. Detailed personality matching means you might be paying through your nose for months and months before getting a match, only to get one that looks like they were run over by a beet truck. But they have a great personality.
back to top
ChemistryChemistry is Match.com's foray into the personality-based dating world. Users fill out a personality profile which is lengthy detailed, but not as involved as eHarmony's profile.
The crowd: Young professionals from all backgrounds. Since this is from Match.com, a lot of their users are trying it.
What's free: To be honest, I am not terribly clear on that. It appears to be 100% free, but I can't tell if that's because I'm a paid Match member or not.
UPDATE: It looks like you do have to pay to contact other people.
What's paid: Contacting other members.
How much: $49.95/month to about $21/month if you prepay for 12 months.
Best features: Superb site design and easy to follow steps for indicating interest or a lack of interest in matches presented to you. Email contact between users cannot be initiated until a series of steps involving answering questions selected by the other person, indicating importance of certain relationship criteria, etc. are completed and both parties agree they still interested through each step.
Worst features: Expensive. Matches are presented each day and don't seem to closely match selected criteria or personality aspects. Based on my one experience meeting someone from this site.
back to top
MySpaceThis site, like
Friendster and others, is actually a social networking website. It ostensibly can be used for finding bands, blogging, meeting friends, catching up with old classmates and coworkers, and making business contacts, but let's face it, this is more meat market than any sweaty night club or bar you've ever stepped foot in. People are there to see and be seen. Eye humping runs rampant.
The crowd: Horny teens challenged in written communication, college students, and the rest of us who laugh at them. It's so popular that even your granny might have a profile.
What's free: All of it, stem to stern.
What's paid: Nothing. Though you do pay for it by being harassed by manic animated banner ads and being visually assaulted and every turn with games, sounds, videos, and eye scarring color schemes users put into their profiles.
How much: Free.
Best features: It's a great forum for local bands to find new listeners and keep in touch with their current fans. A simple environment for first time bloggers. Reading hilariously socially (and grammatically) unacceptable public comments from horndog guys on the profiles and photos of attractive young women.
Worst features: The site is buggy as all hell. Being pounded by literally tens of millions of users often causes slow response times and complete system outages. Every few clicks are sure to result in an error message. Profiles are often offline for "routine maintenance" and features are prone to randomly stop working for days at a time. Advanced profile browsing options are implemented inconsistently. For example, you can search for single women, aged 25 to 34, looking for friends, dating, or serious relationships, but you can only select one option at a time for "Wants kids" and that option curiously includes "Proud Parent". Why not separate Has Kids and Wants Kids like every other site on the planet and let you select multiple options at once for each?
back to top